Arrow 5.09: What We Leave Behind
Wendy Mericle and Beth Schwartz
Antonio Negret
Coming off the
heels of the largely successful four-series DC TV Universe crossover event, it
proved to be difficult getting back into the singular stories of each series.
This was entirely true of The
Flash, which showed a rather forgettable episode recently.
For the first few minutes of this episode, it took a bit of effort personally
to follow along with what's been happening. Oliver asking Thea at the City Hall
Christmas party if she was okay, checking in on her mental status after being
ripped away from the idyllic setting the Dominators created in her mind, felt
like the show asking the same of its viewers. Now that the Dominators were out
of the way -- a one-off kind of thing for the time being -- you have to accept
the reality of what's going on in Star City.
That means
having to bring attention back to the threat of Prometheus and his slow and
steady disintegration of Team Arrow. Yes, it took a bit of time to get back
into the swing of things, but by the end of this episode, it becomes clear that
this is possibly Oliver's most dangerous opponent since Slad Wilson/Deathstroke
back in the halcyon days of season two. Prometheus thoroughly and
systematically brings Oliver and the rest of Team Arrow to its figurative knees
by making everything a personal attack on Oliver. This has been proven
throughout the season to begin with, as Prometheus has brought up the kills
Oliver did as the Hood back in the early days of the series, essentially tying
the past with the present. As we've all seen with season two's Slade Wilson
arc, that's operating right in the show's wheelhouse. I don't think we've seen
Justin Clayborn as one of the Hood's "victims" before, but the show
and the episode wastes little time retroactively making him a member of Robert
Queen's list. And so that personal connection makes it that much easier for
Oliver and Team Arrow, as well as the show's captive audience, to believe that
Clayborn is Prometheus.
Of course, the
show's past history also makes it very easy to believe that all of it is a red
herring. A shell game where the audience thinks he's not Prometheus, then has
to start figuring out who else it might be. The limited list of suspects left
my head spinning at the possibilities. But being a longtime viewer of the
series, I learned to go with the flow, and trust that all the answers will be
provided in due time. So even while I was trying to figure all of that out, the
show can allow enough space to judge Felicity's detective boyfriend as bland
and boring, which meant that his eventual inadvertent murder at the hands of
Oliver as the Green Arrow didn't initially register as a shock. No, what
followed was a series of shockers. Oliver immediately confesses the killing to Team Arrow. It shows that both
he and the show have learned from past mistakes. In the past, Oliver would have
bottled this knowledge up, creating a dramatic wedge between him and Felicity
or him and the rest of the team and that would fuel plotlines for many episodes
to come later.
This action
taken by Prometheus (as part of an elaborate reminder of the Hood's killing of
Justin Clayborn four years before) shakes Oliver to his very core. He tells the
team to stay far away from him, as Prometheus' taunting statement that
"everyone he touches, dies" will lead to every one of their demises,
yet John and the team shows Oliver that they've got his back. Even if their own
personal lives are falling apart. Evelyn betrayed the team to go in league with
Prometheus (and I'm surprised that the writers stuck with that given the strong
possibility that it could've been some tactic by either Evelyn or Team Arrow to
see what Prometheus is up to exactly); Curtis has his husband leave him, for legitimate
reasons; John looks to be in big trouble, likely with the military due to his
breaking out of prison. Felicity has to temporarily mourn the loss of Detective
Tyler. Oliver has to absorb all of this punishment, internalize it, and yet, at
the end, it looks like he has been absolved of the guilt that would normally
have consumed him otherwise.
- Prometheus might be the best villain the series has had since Deathstroke
- Tyler gets a better sendoff than he probably deserved
- That twist at the end is going to need a very good explanation to feel earned