Game of Thrones Review by John Keegan

Game of Thrones 6.07: The Broken Man

Game of Thrones 6.07: The Broken Man

Written By:
Bryan Cogman
Directed By:
Mark Mylod

Despite some disappointment that the brewing battles are still just on the horizon instead of starting in earnest, there were some solid developments as the pieces continue to move and shift on the board.  The game is about to get extremely violent, more so than usual, and perhaps the producers needed to keep the budget under control for a few episodes to allow for the massive events to come.

 


 

The Hound: In an unusual move, the continued existence of the Hound comes in a pre-opening credits scene that marks this as highly significant.  And that’s fine with me, since it seems like a battle between the Mountain and the Hound has been foreshadowed enough since the first season to warrant this level of attention.

 

Perhaps equally significant to some would be the introduction (and eventual dispatch) of Septon Ray, playing by Ian McShane.  The Septon believes there is a greater purpose for the Hound still to be revealed, and unless he was reading ahead in the scripts, that’s just underscoring what was already apparent.  Things were never going to end well for the Septon and his followers, but someone made a very big mistake by making the Hound want to spill some blood again.

 


 

King’s Landing: There was a bit more focus on Margaery in this episode, and what many suspected appears to be true: she is playing the High Sparrow and the Faith Militant to remain Queen.  In some respects, it limits her ability to maneuver, but in others, it provides a lot more freedom than she had in a cell wearing sackcloth.  It wouldn’t be the first time someone saw open declaration and adherence to a faith as the means to political and personal end.

 

While it was inevitable that the High Sparrow would move against Lady Olenna, at least the Queen of Thorns was given the option of returning to Highgarden and retaining some degree of autonomy.  At this point, the High Sparrow could have easily had her tossed in a dungeon and House Tyrell would have had little ability to prevent it.

                                                                                                                                       


 

Jon and Sansa: I suppose it was inevitable that the Starks would run into resistance in their recruiting drive.  The Wildlings have every reason to follow Jon after Hardhome, but what about the Stark bannermen?  As it turns out, that marriage to Ramsey works against Sansa, and Jon’s bastard status doesn’t win many points either.  It’s a fair point that they have only tenuous claim over the Stark name at this point.  Even House Mormont, led by the delightfully spunky Lyanna, needs a great deal of convincing, despite having backed Robb Stark claim to the throne.

 

Most of the other allies to the Starks either choose to sit the battle for Winterfell out or all but commit to fighting on the opposite side if the Boltons call on them.  That leaves Sansa with little choice but to call on outside aid.  Chances are this is Littlefinger, since he has been gathering forces on Sansa’s behalf (supposedly) for some time now.  What’s less clear is why she wouldn’t simply tell Jon what she has in mind, since all this is going to do is drive them apart once the dust clears.  (Which has to happen anyway, since Jon is meant for more than sitting around Winterfell.)

 


 

Riverrun: Jamie and Bronn arrive to find that the Blackfish forces are well-entrenched and the army laying siege is entirely incompetent.  Oh, and so much for the notion that threatening Edmure Tully would sway the Blackfish from keeping his new prize.  Jamie’s attempt to parly is rebuffed rather nicely, which seems to give Jamie little recourse but to prepare for an assault.  As expected, a Battle of Riverrun is brewing in the near future.

 

But this still raises the question of what might happen once Brienne arrives.  Could she persuade Jamie that there is a much bigger fight than the one he was tasked with by the High Sparrow?  It seems doubtful, but stranger things have happened.  It is equally possible (and perhaps narratively necessary) for Jamie and Brienne to face each other on the battlefield, but I’m hoping that the writers will do something a little less expected.

 


 

Volantis: Theon and Yara stop here on the way to Slaver’s Bay, and it’s hard to see what the point of the exercise is.  An excuse to have Yara be libertine and remind the audience that Theon doesn’t have the equipment for it anymore?  Or simply to push Theon into getting his attitude back, now that he’s not Reek anymore?  It seems the latter, though one would hope that he would find some middle ground between his former arrogance and his current over-humility. 

 

Arya the Still-Blind: At least, that’s what she must be, not to see the attack from the Waif coming a mile away.  How Arya survives being gutted is a bit of a mystery, never mind getting back on her feet and walking around, but one would have expected her sudden sense of paranoia in the streets of Braavos would have been in place the minute she turned on the Faceless Men.  At least we know her story isn’t over, and it’s likely that her feud with the Waif will end very soon.  Whether or not this is what Jaqen wants, or he is next on the list, remains to be seen.

 


 

If there is a major concern with three episodes left for the season, it’s the possibility that all these brewing conflicts will interfere with one another when it comes to adequate screen time.  There’s an outside chance that Riverrun will be a red herring and those forces will all move on Winterfell from the south, but even then, the battle to retake Winterfell is going to coincide with whatever happens in Meereen at this point.  That’s a lot to cover in a short period of time.
 
Our Grade:
B
The Good:
  • The Hound returns and looks ready to inflict some pain
  • The preparations to retake Winterfell are definitely intriguing
The Bad:
  • What exactly was the point of the scene in Volantis?
  • Arya seemed to forget the capabilities of her opponents rather quickly

John Keegan aka "criticalmyth", is one of the hosts of the "Critical Myth" podcast heard here on VOG Network's radio feed Monday, Wednesday & Friday. You can follow him on twitter at @criticalmyth

Game of Thrones by - 6/7/2016 9:36 AM303 views

Your Responses

Flaco_Jones
Flaco_Jones
CONCURRING OPINION

Grade: B-
Despite the Hound and Margery stories carrying the episode, the stuff with Arya was laughably bad. I have this sense of dread about divine intervention interjecting into the story a bit too often, as was hinted at by the septum's talk with the Hound. Death is beginning to mean very little on this show, at least when it pertains to main characters, when it was such a strong factor early on. What's next, Robb and Ned showing up, heads stitched back on? Stannis being alive wouldn't shock me either.

Registered Participants can leave their own Concurring/Dissenting Opinion and receive Points and Loot! Why not sign in and add your voice?

Comments

Log in to add your own voice and receive points by leaving good comments other users like!