Review by John Keegan

Review of Stargate: Atlantis: Legacy: The Furies by Jo Graham

Review of Stargate: Atlantis: Legacy: The Furies by Jo Graham

The post-finale "Legacy" series has been one of the better examples of this tie-in novel strategy.  Other shows have used novels (or, more recently, comics) to finish out or otherwise extend the story beyond the televised adventures.  The example that most resembles the "Legacy" concept, in my mind, is the "Roswell" set of novels that wrapped up that show's mythology.

"Legacy" has been most successful in its approach to the characters.  Over the course of the four books already released (out of a total of six), the vast majority of the page count has been devoted to in-depth character study and evolution of relationships.  That's not to say that there hasn't been plenty of action; it's just that the authors have been more focused on the characters than the actual episodes tended to be.  The characters are actually changing, growing, and evolving.

It's important to keep that in mind, because despite bringing the second act of "Legacy" more or less to a close, "The Furies" is remarkably low on action.  The very end has a stirring action sequence, and there's a big moment in the first half, but more than 90% of the book is devoted to characters talking to one another.  Enjoyment of this novel is going to depend greatly on one's patience for that sort of material, especially when entire chapters roll by with conversations and E-mails to off-page characters that merely allude to a larger context.

For fans of the entire franchise, particularly "SG-1" and "Atlantis" and those focused on certain possible romantic relationships, this is all gravy.  But it does mean that the pacing is sometimes slow and erratic, and there are times when it feels like there's no clear direction to the narrative.  One gets the sense of pieces moving on the board, but the game plan isn't apparent.  This is, by far, the least focused of the "Legacy" novels to date.

The highlight of the novel would have to be Teyla's plot thread, which ties back into her character's history in several important ways.  It's also connected to the ongoing exploration of Todd/Guide's character, and by extension, the deeper exploration of the Wraith, which has been a highlight of the "Legacy" books.  All too often, giving too much context to the enemy can undermine their effectiveness; this is not the case for the Wraith in "Legacy".

There is more than enough here to sustain the interest of any die-hard "Stargate: Atlantis" fan, and since one is likely to be that devoted if they are looking for further adventures, then this is highly recommended for that audience.  Casual fans may find that it meanders a bit too much for their taste, and references enough of the "Stargate" franchise's history to make some connections and thought processes a bit confusing.  But to be honest, I doubt too many casual readers would be picking this up in the first place.


Our Grade:
B-
The Good:
* Deep character exploration
* Strong ties to the "Stargate" continuity
* Excellent Teyla, Todd, and Wraith plot threads
The Bad:
* Lacking in action
* Somewhat unfocused
* Can be difficult for fans that don't remember minute details of the franchise

John Keegan aka "criticalmyth", is one of the hosts of the "Critical Myth" podcast heard here on VOG Network's radio feed Monday, Wednesday & Friday. You can follow him on twitter at @criticalmyth

Review by - 8/13/2012 6:55 PM387 views

Your Responses

Registered Participants can leave their own Concurring/Dissenting Opinion and receive Points and Loot! Why not sign in and add your voice?

Comments

PodCulture
PodCulture
8/13/2012 7:12 PM

2 0

Reply
Glad to see some Stargate love on the VOG site. While SG1 may have run its course a season or two too long, SGA still had a couple more good years in it, and SGU got cut down just when it was really getting good!

Kinda makes make me want to drag the old STARGATE: LOUISVILLE podcast out of mothballs for a special episode or something.
criticalmyth
criticalmyth
8/13/2012 8:09 PM

0 0

Reply
Brad: Have you been keeping up with the Legacy books? I vaguely recall you mentioning the first one on PodCulture a while back.

This was my least favorite, I think, but still had stuff I loved, especially the Teyla stuff. In fact, I would have killed to see that play out on-screen!
PodCulture
PodCulture
8/14/2012 9:06 AM

0 0

Reply
I have, but I think I am a book or two behind.
VxJasonxV
VxJasonxV
8/23/2012 7:31 PM

0 0

Reply
Having grown up as a Trekkie...

Ok, scratch that. That's 100% not true.

Having grown up with Star Trek and Star Wars being the only sci-fi universes I really paid any attention to, it's been incredibly fun to take in the Stargate franchise en massé. Over the past year I've watched the whole series of SG-1 including all three movies, Stargate Atlantis, and Stargate Universe.

Only recently did I discover that the story continued with the original cast in these books. Biased I may be given how recently I've watched ALL of the Stargate content, but I don't consider referencing minute details of a series a Con.

Thank you so much for reviewing this and calling attention to it. I was on the fence about checking them out, but now I'm 100% on board with doing so. Now the real question... Audiobooks or Kindle versions?

I'm sure Blackwolf has a suggestion that is in no way fiscally motivated :). <3
Log in to add your own voice and receive points by leaving good comments other users like!