The Flash 4.01: The Flash Reborn
Andrew Kreisberg, Todd Helbing, and Eric Wallace
Glen Winter
Let's get this out of the way so that I don't
have to discuss it any further: The third season of The Flash was not good. That's being somewhat generous. I think the
writers and those in charge of the show knew this was the opinion in general,
and it looks like they've put in the time while the show is off the air to make
some corrections. The fact that the writers are trying to go all the way back
to a slight emulation of the first season (still the show's most successful
one) is a bit of a strange direction to take. It makes the writers look like
they can't seem to move on from that season. Or that they continually try to
re-capture the magic of that season with mixed results (it isn't the first time
this kind of thing has been tried). It'll take a few episodes to really see if
the changes take.
Immediately, though, the changes are evident.
With Barry stuck in the Speed Force, Team Flash (or Team Vibe or Team Kid
Flash, according to either Cisco or Wally) needs a new leader, and that somehow
became Iris. Seeing a more confident and direct Iris is refreshing, especially
in light of the fact that she has spent much of the show so far being the
damsel in distress or the one person left completely out of the loop. Iris' new
attitude would also feel unique if I hadn't recently watched the season
premiere of Supergirl, which has Kara
going through basically the same story arc. Both women are trying to cope with
the loss of their loved ones, mostly by overcompensating and overdoing their
jobs in the superhero arena.
The key difference is that while Kara Danvers
likely won't see her lover ever again, there is the very real possibility that
Iris will see Barry again. Putting aside the fact that the show is named after
him, and the show rarely functions for long without him in the picture, it's
only a matter of time before someone or something breaks Barry out of the Speed
Force. The show does give a good crack at trying, though. There's Wally, who is
the team's resident speedster, even if he's only an approximation of Barry's
capability. Cisco seems more comfortable with his Vibe powers, and Joe can
provide great support with the assistance of the Central City Police
Department. Taking out Peek-a-Boo in the first act proved that the team could
operate well enough at least to keep the more manageable villains at bay. When
a bigger threat shows up, such as a hulking, flying samurai with a powerful
sword, the deficiencies of the team start to come up. Tricking the samurai by
having Wally masquerade as Barry is snuffed out quickly, though that was more
of a strategic failure on Wally's part than anything regarding the team's
decisions on how to combat the episode's central villain.
It's actually Cisco's repeated attempts to find
a way to break Barry out of the Speed Force that causes the internal conflict
holding Iris back. The confident bravado and leadership skills she showed in
the beginning were used as a shield against her accepting the fact that Barry
is gone, never to return. Like Kara on Supergirl,
Iris' grief adds to the drama quotient of the episode, and it's handled better
than I would have expected. The Flash
is supposed to be pulpy fun. Handling heavier, darker emotions has never been
quite in its wheelhouse, as last season can attest. The writers want to get to
the reset point as quickly as possible, and that means largely forgetting about
last season.
Where things are fumbled a bit with Iris, the
show compensates by revealing wholesale changes to Caitlin's character. At the
end of last season, she told the team that she wasn't quite Killer Frost, but
she's also not quite Caitlin either. Now, she's working as a bartender in a
biker bar, while doing some shady side jobs for someone named Amunet that isn't
made very clear in the episode. She readily helps Cisco and the team get Barry
out of the Speed Force and diagnose his condition once released, but the end of
the episode reveals that she's struggling to control the Killer Frost persona.
While this is an interesting development for the character in general, I'm
cringing at the possibility that the writers will extend this Jekyll-and-Hyde
act in the season for too long a time.
Barry's "condition" when he's
released from the Speed Force looks like some advanced form of dementia or
fugue state. In addition to constantly writing non-sensical symbols on any
surface (I don't buy Cisco's translation of "This house is bitchin'"
as sensible for one second) available to him, he spouts dialogue from the
series' past mixed with some random phrases that only a "crazy"
person on television would say in order to sound crazy. I briefly had the
theory that maybe the team had gotten a Barry from a future time, but that
would be a foolish choice from the writers given the myriad timeline
manipulations of the past two seasons.
Like Iris' assertion that she had permanently
lost Barry, Barry's "condition" proves only temporary. Iris had to
get herself in the middle of life-threatening danger for the "real"
Barry to resurface again, but it was accomplished in order for The Flash to show off another CGI-filled
action set piece (spectacular as it was) and to reset the series enough to get
back to near its original state. Team Flash is whole again, with its leader now
in possession of a new and improved suit along with presumably six months'
worth of knowledge from the Speed Force. It's almost as if nothing has changed
in three years. Almost.
- The dramatic elements with Iris work better than one would expect after last season’s mess
- The writers need to stop chasing the high points of the first season; it’s holding the show back