The Leftovers 1.10: The Prodigal Son Returns
Damon Lindelof and Tom Perrota
Mimi Leder
The
Leftovers
is a notoriously difficult show to watch; it is an even more difficult show to
review. The subject matter is so
psychological that reactions are almost entirely subjective. It either resonates or it doesn’t, and a lot
of people are going to be turned away simply by the hopelessness permeating the
entire series. When all of the
characters are damaged, maybe even beyond the point of repair, it can be fairly
break viewing.
There is a substantial number of viewers
angry that there isn’t a set of easily digested mysteries to solve. Lindelof is perhaps doubling down on the
criticisms of Lost by essentially telling
the audience that there are the things that simply happen and the choices people
make as a result. Why things happen isn’t
nearly as important as the meaning that we ascribe, the choices we make in
response, and the consequences that we accept or reject.
Hence my ongoing depiction of the Guilty
Remnant as spoiled children, lashing out at the world for not reacting to tragedy
in the same way they choose to, for moving on.
It becomes incredibly clear by the end of this episode that most of them
don’t embrace the abyss that Patti had; instead, they pretend at anonymity
while plotting way to make themselves more visible. They seek attention, and not only that, but
negative attention. They take survivors’
guilt to the extreme and plot ways to force others to lash out against
them. It’s about as self-indulgent a
form of self-loathing as it gets.
This is all backdrop to Kevin’s long dark
night of the soul, as he begins to realize that he’s the unreliable narrator of
his own worldview. Matters have spun so
far out of control that he’s not even sure what the hell is going on
anymore. It was all too easy to believe
that he was in that institution, falling deeper into madness than his
father. Embracing the tenuous threads of
hope, offered by a false prophet, is all he has left, and events conspire to
make it seem like faith in something, even something potentially (and likely)
false, is better than sliding into nihilism.
This is reflected in the Biblical passage recited by Kevin, which is all
about faith without proof or foundation.
The entire season, and this episode, might be summed up by the montage accompanied by the haunting rendition of Metallica’s “Nothing Else Matters” by Apocalyptica. It captured the tone of the show perfectly. Ending with Nora’s somewhat terrifying farewell, forestalled by the most unlikely of circumstances, points to the endgame: even when it seems hopeless, there is a reason to carry on.
- Brings together the messages of the series well
- The direction is excellent
- It’s hard to know where things will go from here